The Impact of Uncertainty on Business: A Delicate Balance
useppe velocity of Change in Economic Policy
In the first weeks of the second Trump administration, the U.S. economy has been thrust into a period of unprecedented uncertainty. The rapid-fire changes in economic policy—spending freezes, agency shutdowns, tariff fluctuations—have created a whirlwind that has left even the most seasoned business leaders struggling to keep up. Measures of economic policy uncertainty have skyrocketed to levels typically associated with global crises and recessions. This turmoil has sparked a heated debate: Can businesses thrive in such an environment, or will uncertainty prove to be a significant drag on economic activity?
Business Leaders Navigate a Chaotic Landscape
Business leaders, many of whom celebrated President Trump’s election victory with optimism about lower taxes and reduced regulation, are now grappling with the unpredictable nature of the new administration’s policies.Executives like Nicholas Pinchuk of Snap-on, Jim Farley of Ford, and Chad Coulter of Biscuit Belly have expressed frustration with the constant shifts in policy, describing the situation as "chaotic" and "costly."Despite these challenges, many business leaders remain surprisingly upbeat. Measures of business confidence surged after the election, and while there are signs that this optimism may be wavering, the overall mood remains positive.
The Battle Between Optimism and Uncertainty
According to Stanford University professor Nicholas Bloom, who has studied the impact of uncertainty on the economy, businesses are currently caught in a tug-of-war between heightened optimism and heightened uncertainty."You’ve really got a battle between greater business optimism and greater business uncertainty, and they’re kind of opposing forces," Bloom said.This delicate balance is evident in the actions of business leaders, who are cautiously proceeding with planned investments even as they express concerns about the future. For many small businesses, the immediate priority is preserving tax breaks set to expire at the end of the year, and there is growing anxiety about whether Congress will reach a deal to extend these provisions.
The Costs of Uncertainty
Economists have long warned that uncertainty can have a chilling effect on business activity, leading to reduced hiring and investment. Recent research by Steven J. Davis of Stanford University and others has quantified this impact, showing that uncertainty creates a kind of "limbo" for businesses, making it difficult to plan for the future.Kim Vaccarella, founder of Bogg Bag, a company that manufactures brightly colored totes, is grappling with this reality firsthand. With new tariffs on imports from China threatening to add $2.50 to the wholesale cost of each bag, Vaccarella is exploring alternatives like moving production to Sri Lanka or Vietnam. But with trade policies changing weekly, she finds herself stuck in a state of indecision.
Pulling Back: The Practical Implications of Uncertainty
As uncertainty mounts, businesses are taking steps to mitigate their exposure to potential risks. For companies like Snap-on, this has meant shifting production to lower-cost items and hedging against potential tariffs by stockpiling materials.Yet these adaptations come at a cost. Economists argue that such decisions—like buying inventory before it’s needed or altering production schedules—distort the normal functioning of the economy, creating inefficiencies that act like a "tax" on business activity.For consumers, the impact of uncertainty may be more immediate. With fears of higher prices due to tariffs and concerns about the broader economic climate, many Americans are choosing to "hunker down" and hold onto their money, a trend that could have significant implications for consumer spending.
The Broader Economic Implications
While the U.S. economy has shown remarkable resilience in recent months, the long-term consequences of the current uncertainty remain to be seen. Gregory Brown, a finance professor at the University of North Carolina, suggests that while businesses may dial back some investments, they are unlikely to come to a complete halt—as long as sales remain strong and the economy appears stable.Yet there are real risks on the horizon. If the turbulence in Washington fails to subside, confidence could begin to erode, leading to slower hiring and investment. For small businesses like Biscuit Belly, the North Carolina-based breakfast chain, the uncertainty is particularly acute. Founder Chad Coulter worries not only about specific policies—like the impact of immigration crackdowns on labor costs or tariffs on construction expenses—but also about the broader psychological toll of constant change on consumer behavior.As the situation unfolds, one thing is clear: The next few months will be critical in determining whether businesses can continue to thrive in the face of unprecedented uncertainty.
